Columbine by Dave Cullen.

I took an accidental sabbatical from this blog. I got busy with kids and homeschooling and laundry and watching The Biggest Loser back episodes. Anyway, blah(g), blah(g), blah(g). I'm back. In the deafening silence, I did manage to plow through many excellent books, one of which was Dave Cullen's Columbine. Also, I got a Nook. But I'll save that for another post.


I did not follow the Columbine school shooting story beyond the initial media frenzy in 1999, so I probably wouldn't have picked up the book had it not garnered so much attention. The book won big (see here: left sidebar). So big, that I became curious how Cullen could have managed to provide a fresh, engrossing reassembling of facts which had to be, at this point, a matter of public record.

Cullen structures the book telescopically. He begins with a distant sketch of the shooters, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, and the culture surrounding Columbine High School's other students and faculty. At first, Cullen paints imprecise impressions of Eric and Dylan, similar to ones non-intimate peers and teachers likely would've had about them. As the book progresses, he funnels toward the two boys, padding the skeletons of their characters and psyches with chilling, heartbreaking detail. An investigative reporter, Cullen relies on scrupulously picked-over court records, eye-witness accounts, interviews, and the killers' journals and home videos to unwrap the what, when, and how of April 20th, 1999 and the event's frenzied aftermath of confusion, scandal, and factual incongruity. The suck-in-your-breath factor of the book, however, is Cullen's well-reasoned (and well-documented) supposition for why the shooters attempted to kill all of their classmates and teachers. Systematically debunking all of the favored media explanations ("It was the Trench Coat Mafia! They hated the jocks! And the Christians!"), Cullen calls on some of the most invested, experienced mental health experts privy to the details of the case to give us a window into the minds of Columbine's infamous killers. The book also weaves together the stories of the survivors--students, parents, and faculty--who continue to fumble toward healing in different ways.

I am a mother of three kids with a low tolerance for horror. I practically had to hide The Lovely Bones by Alice Sebold under my bed at night because it freaked me out, irreparably. (Frailty, thy name is Home Girl). However, Cullen handles a terrifying topic with a sensitive alchemy of abstraction and vernacular detail that kept me reading. For two solid days, and at the expense of all else, as it were. He manages to fit the tangle of events and characters into a deeply compelling arch that--by some writerly sleight of hand--deescalates into a satisfying ending. Serious skillz. Who could "end" a book on Columbine without leaving us straining for a resolving chord? But Cullen pulls it off. I sincerely hope he writes more books.

Have you read Columbine by Dave Cullen? Also, I'll finish book #32 for the year this week toward my goal. I think I'm a teensy bit behind schedule. What about you?

22 comments:

StephTheBookworm said...

I read this book and thought it was probably the best non-fiction book I read last year.

Stephanie said...

This is one I probably will read at some point in the future. It sounds intriguing.

My brain is fried this year. Just fried. I haven't read nearly the amount that I have in years past. Half the stuff I get at the library, I return unread (and I NEVER used to do that). I don't know what it is- maybe because I'm writing more and I don't have the brainpower needed to read? Or maybe it's because I sit and read with my son from 9 in the morning til about 2 or 3 in the afternoon (we homeschool, and we're- surprise!- very literature based, so we do a LOT of reading). Maybe my brain is full already? I don't know. But I'm right there with you on being behind!

Rachel said...

Stephanie--I return unread books to the library ALL. THE. TIME. And, to pour lemon juice into the paper cut, I have to pay late fines on them, because I keep them beyond the due date, believing (against all evidence) that I'll read them very soon.

thelittlereader.net said...

i picked this book up on a random trip to the bookstore, but haven't had a chance to read it yet. i keep hearing such good things about it, so i'm sure i'll enjoy it when i get some time to read it.

as for my reading this year, i'm doing surprisingly well. i just finished book #43, so i'm on track to hit the 100 mark, which will be a first for me.

good luck on getting back on track with your goals and thanks for the great review!

Novel Discussions said...

My book club read Columbine a couple months ago. We all pretty much agreed it was one of the best nonfiction books we've ever read. It was also one of the most horrifying. It was particularly emotional for me because I was in high school at the time of the shootings. Great review.

gm said...

Cullen , who first reported on the story for the online magazine Salon, acknowledges in the book's source notes that thoughts he attributes to Klebold and Harris are conjecture gleaned from the record the pair left behind.

Jeff Kass takes a more straightforward approach in "Columbine: A True Crime Story," working backward from the events of the fateful day.
The Denver Post

Mr. Cullen insists that the killers enjoyed "far more friends than the average adolescent," with Harris in particular being a regular Casanova who "on the ultimate high school scorecard . . . outscored much of the football team." The author's footnotes do not reveal how he knows this; when I asked him about it while preparing this review, Mr. Cullen said he did not necessarily mean to imply that Harris was sexually active. But what else would such words mean?

"Eric and Dylan never had any girlfriends," the more sober Mr. Kass writes, and were "probably virgins upon death."
Wall Street Journal

fredamans said...

I couldn't read that story, the subject matter really disgusts me.
I appreciate your review all the same.

I hit my 100 mark a while ago. On 115 now.... lol

Rachel said...

I think it is acceptable that Cullen used the word "score" to imply more tame sexual/relational attention from the opposite sex. Eric dated a 23 year old and had some female friends that seemed to look up to him. I believe Cullen was intentionally adopting a "highschool" vernacular when talking about the boys' modest popularity with the opposite sex. In the book, Cullen admits that he is speculating about the reasons behind the killings; however, he presents a compelling, believable case for drawing the conclusions he draws.

Tina's Blog said...

I haven't read it yet, but it is still on my list. I have also wondered how there could be any new information on this topic, or a fresh outlook on it. Thanks for reminding me about this one!

Kathleen said...

I read this book and was amazed at how the news coverage about Columbine got so many things wrong. The book made me really sad. There were so many opportunities for the parents of the killers to notice something and they just didn't do it.

Emma said...

Wow, stellar review. I'll definitely have to read this one.

bookjourney said...

I am currently reading this book and I am just amazed. I think I have cried three times through out the book so far - one of those times is when the Principal speaks to the kids after the shootings and the reaction....

I am on track for my reading so far this year...

Oh and welcome back! :D

Dave Cullen said...

Homegirl, thanks for the really thoughtful review of my book. I am always happy with good reviews, obviously, but I appreciate it much more when I see the thought you've put into it. You really got what I was going for.

Your commenters did, too. Rachel, you got it on me working in the high school vernacular. I had nine storylines, and tried to tell each from the point of view of the main character (all in the third person, with me as narrator, but considering what that person knew, thought, and felt at the time, and subtly infused by their thoughts, feelings and language.)

(BTW, GM is a Denver businessman who published the book he he pimping there.)

Much thanks to Steph, Kathleen, Rachel, Novel Discussions and bookjourney for the kind words. And thanks for all the interest from you others. I look forward to hearing what you think, good or bad.

Jen said...

i hope your nook works for you. Im on my third... *bangs head against a wall*

Adam Wilson said...

I ranked this as the best non-fiction book I have ever read! I can't recommend it enough.

You can read my review of it at http://www.lettersonpages.com/2009/04/columbine-by-dave-cullen/

Lux Lea said...

My review is here:

http://luxlioness.blogspot.com/2010/01/it-is-monday-and-im-reading-columbine.html#comments

I loved your view how Cullen wrote bringing the two boys closer and in more detail as the book went along. Great insight!

ldsjaneite said...

I liked that adapted S&S quote! :-)

I've been wanting to read this book--even before the good reviews that came out. But I remember how much I was affected when the shooting occurred, and I'm not sure how well I can handle it. Not just yet.

Jennie Smith said...

Definitely adding this one. I was a senior in high school when this happened and completely remember everything. I am interested to see it and now that I am reading all of these wonderful reviews I am... going to order it now! Great review!

Happy reading!

TommyGirl said...

I read the book and it was interesting and horrifying at the same time. There was so much information that seemed to get messed up in the aftermath and the looks inside the psyches of the two shooters was scary and yet informative.

Susan said...

I found this book completely engrossing, too. It freaked me out and gave me nightmares, but also helped me understand the events better and empathize more with all involved. Great book.

Ink, Pulp said...

I saw Columbine a while ago and have been debating wether it is something I should read. I was in high school when it happened and I think I will get more out of it now that time has passed.
btw, props to David Cullen for leaving a comment. I love hearing from the authors directly. It's like a digital book signing. : )

Aths said...

I read this book last month, and really loved it! It will make my top list this year. The research Dave Cullen did is so amazing - the amount of lies that spawned right after the tragedy really amazes me!